Ivan Zhao
简繁EN

From the week

A question someone could actually answer

An internal role-play about a fictional company stalled at the most politely worded question on my sheet.

I had the interview outline in an internal exercise this week. The case was a fictional manufacturer, with plausible descriptions of purchasing, production and shipments. In the margin I wrote “Please elaborate on the use of funds” and felt I had phrased it safely.

When my colleague took the role of the business owner, the safe wording produced little. He repeated the material about buying inputs, paying wages and settling suppliers. I waited for detail; he waited for the next question. Neither of us had said anything wrong, but we had stopped getting anywhere.

I tried a different question: if this borrowing did not arrive for now, which agreed payment would be affected first? That sent him back to the purchasing arrangement rather than to a summary of what the business did. We went on to supplier instalments, whether the materials matched orders already received, and the gap between shipping and getting paid. The exercise stopped short of an approval decision. We were establishing where the money would remain tied up.

Those questions would not make a universal questionnaire. I began with an agreed payment because the exercise already included a purchasing arrangement. A case involving new equipment would start with installation and production, not another question about raw materials. The outline could remind me of omissions without dictating the order of every conversation.

The most professional-sounding lines needed the most rewriting. Instead of asking whether operating conditions had changed, I asked whether an order had recently been delayed. Instead of asking whether collections were normal, I asked what had happened to money originally expected to arrive. Once someone could describe one event, I had something to follow up.

I left “Please elaborate” on the sheet with a line after it rather than deleting it. When I wrote it, I had not known what was missing. The finished outline was shorter, with more empty space beside the questions for follow-ups.

My colleague offered to ask the questions next time. I am not entirely keen to play the owner. I suspect I would keep replying, “It depends.”